Summary

More often than not, raw emotion is at the core of horror games. While terrifying monsters and creepy mansions can spook players on their own, adding anelement of psychological horrorwith a well-written story/script takes the scares up to a whole new level of terror.

Immersion is key in horror games; if it doesn’t seem like the characters are scared, how are players expected to feel scared? Fortunately for horror fans, there are a handful of great horror games that do an outstanding job of ensuring their audiences are fully invested. Here are some horror games featuring the best acting performances.

A half-covered portrait of a woman in Layers of Fear.

Layers Of Feartells the story of how such a loving family finds their tragic end in the search for never-fading beauty. The story is told in narrated flashbacks of the main character, known as The Painter. The entirety ofLayers Of Fear’s story relied on Erik Braa’s interpretation of The Painter; and thankfully, he did an amazing job making the story his. As the game progresses and the player unveils the story behind The Painter and his wife, audiences see The Painter’s love for his wife slowly wither away, transforming into disgust and resentment.

Rule Of Rosefollows Jennifer, a young girl who is at the mercy of the powerful Red Rose Aristocracy, led by the mysterious Prince and Princess of the Red Rose. Jennifer’s memories of her past are slowly uncovered through the game’s horrific events, creating a dramatic, fantasy-like version of what had actually taken place in Jennifer’s childhood.

Layers of Fear (2023) Tag Page Cover Art

Wyatt’s performance as Jennifer in the scene where she finally stands up for herself and protests against the aristocracy was chilling and made that one moment in the game unforgettable. The despair, disappointment, and resentment Jennifer had for both herself and the aristocracy was clearly heard, all thanks to Wyatt’s voice talents.

Amnesiastill stands as one of the most iconic horror games of all time. It was truly ahead of its time and offered an incredible, immersive journey through the haunting corridors of the Brennenburg Castle. The player takes the role of Daniel, a man who has suddenly regained consciousness and is doomed touncover all his memoriesaround the castle through diary excerpts written by himself.

Rule of Rose red crayon aristocrats and jennifer

Richard Topping’s rendition of Daniel did a fantastic job of telling the tales of each horrifying diary entry players slowly find along the way. Without Topping’s talent for storytelling (and the great audio design),Amnesiawouldn’t have made such a lasting memory for players as it did.

While most ofUntil Dawn’s story revolves around Sam and her friends stuck in the cabin at Blackwood Mountain, Peter Stormare’s performance as Dr. Hill truly blew audiences away. Stormare plays Dr. Hill, also known as “The Analyst”. Dr. Hill is The Psycho’s therapist and is only ever seen in cutscenes that take place inside The Psycho’s mind.

Rule Of Rose Tag Page Cover Art

Stormare’s take on Dr. Hill draws audiences in with his gentle portrayal of an understanding therapist slowly twisting into a more antagonizing aggressor. Despite Stormare’s limited screen time, his performance as Dr. Hill stood out, making theUntil Dawnexperience that much more chilling.

The moment players heard Mr. Baker’s iconic, “welcome to the family, son” line from the famousRE7demo, they knew they were up against a terrifying antagonist. Brand’s performance as Jack had players on the edge of their seats every time they heard Jack coming around the corner or lurking down the hallway.

Player reminds himself of his purpose through his writings

Not only did Brand do a fantastic job of portraying Jack Baker’smold-possessed side, but also pulled on the audience’s heartstrings by giving us a window into how kind and caring Jack Baker used to be before Eveline’s cruel takeover.

Troy Baker’s performance as Joel Miller takes the front stage, but that doesn’t mean that his costars are any less talented. The entire cast ofThe Last Of Usgave the performance of a lifetime, as the game’s subject matter is so emotionally heavy by its nature. The only reasonThe Last Of Usdidn’t officially make it onto the list isn’t because of its talented cast, but rather its genre. While the game features zombies and lots of horror elements, it focuses more on more heartfelt philosophical topics about grief, regret, sacrifice, and love.

Amnesia The Dark Descent Tag Page Cover Art

Horror (as a genre) in the world ofThe Last Of Ustakes a backseat to other triumphing concepts and themes.The Last Of Usno doubt has some of the most impressive acting performances in gaming history, but isn’t a true horror game.

Luke Roberts was undoubtedly the heart and soul of the long-awaitedSilent Hill 2 Remake. Roberts' take on James was certainly different from Guy Cihi’s performance inthe original gamebut didn’t disrespect the originalSH2and, instead, gave James even more depth as the tragic character he is. Every moment of James' journey throughout Silent Hill is agonizing; whether it be because of terrifying monsters, being on the defensive when talking to Eddie, or the strain of desperately trying to repress his memories.

Dawn Hill Dr. Hill Office Interview

James' agony and suffering are at the core of both Silent Hill as the town andSilent Hill 2as the game. Roberts' heart-wrenching performance as James Sunderland gave theSH2remake the astounding immersion it needed to maintain the series' signature cinematic edge.

Until Dawn (2015) Tag Page Cover Art

Resident Evil 7 Jack Baker attacking Ethan Winters

Resident Evil 7: Biohazard Tag Page Cover Art